Thanks for the incompetence, Mel "I wanna be just like John L Smith" Tucker
Post-Indiana, the ES doesn't know where to start, other than the obvious: Fire Coach Tucker for the incompetence we saw on Saturday in the loss to an 0-38-when-down-by-17-at-half-since-2003 Indiana team.
FireCoachTuck.com? No, and that's because there's a simple reason. The ludicrous $95 million/10 year contract signed by the athletics department to hire a guy with little-to-no head coaching experience (ok, should we count one year of coaching at national power U Colorado as something?). Problem is, two years into the fraught-ridden deal, MSU would be on the hook for the last 7 years of the contract. Thanks to Matt Ishbia and the St. Andre guy, they agreed to pay half of the salary to hire him, but none of the salary (aka "Golden Parachute") to fire him. So, MSU paying Tuck $66.5 million (last 7 years on contract) not to coach and sit on a sofa eating cheese puffs is a bit ridiculous.
But, someone else should create FireCoachTuck.com to put some pressure on the staff to get them to get their head out of their arse and stop acting like John L. Smith with the "outsmarting himself" decisions, pep-down speeches, and halftime adjustment failures. Clearly, it's not working. Setting up for a field goal on the two-yard line with a questionable-at-best FG unit in a driving, freezing windstorm isn't exactly good coaching. OK, Spartan fans, everyone watching, raise your hands if you were saying on the final drive "We gotta score a TD, I'm not confident in our FG unit." Thought so, all of us felt that way... except of course, for coach Tuck. Listen, coach, you gotta coach from 30,000 feet as much as from the field level and use your authority to make a little better decision for the team and the Spartan Nation instead of acting like this is the NFL. Either get a new pair of glasses to see the reality on the field and make better decisions or fire guys like d-coord Scottie Hazelton who can't produce any consistent play in the defensive unit (your honor, just look at exhibit A: giving up gashing 20-to-30 yard runs to an Indiana QB after stifling nation-leading Illinois RB Chase Brown is irrational).
It is painfully obvious that we Spartans were spoiled with Kenneth Walker III in 2021, who put the Spartans on his back and ran like wild to an impressive 11-2 record. This year, coach Tuck followed the John L Smith stuff-the-roster-with-JUCOs script with his tapping the transfer portal ad nauseum. Note to Tuck: it doesn't work. You gotta recruit and develop talent, not spend your time trying to find once-in-a-lifetime lightning in a bottle.
Unfortunately, 2022 year was the return of the "Same Old Spartans" and very much resembled an overcoached (lack of focus on fundamentals) and underperforming (losing record) transfer-filled Spartan team all year long. This dud of a season will be the remembrance of coach Tuck's decisions which impersonated slap-yo-mamma John L. Smith (the L stood for "laughter" or "loser", your choice).
Victory for MSU? Nope. Same Old Spartans? Yup. Thanks for making MSU a laughing-stock again, the pride of averageness and incompetence, coach Tuck. And Good Luck against Penn State, LMAO.
Land of the free... Little Pink Hoosiers for you and me, babe
Methinks with the cold windy weather, this game is going to be a challenge for both teams, and that means defense will steal the show. While Sparty is having a sub-par year, there is a bowl bid on the line... and Indiana, well nothing's changed, they still have Little Pink Houses for you and me.
This year, Sparty and Indy are once again dancing in the doldrums of mediocrity.
The way both teams are playing, it reminds me of how both teams fared in similar sitnts from average George Perlees-esque years, or par Bobby Williams 2002, or underperforming John L Smith (pick the year), or boring Mark Dantonio 2019. Not really glory years, very ho-hum AVERAGE football.
Today will be a ho-hum game between an average team and a perpetual wanna be "runt of the litter". Harumph. I'm a bit scared on Thorne throwing it through the air lately, some of his mid-range and short passes are just flat and off. But, he does throw a damn fine long ball. A few of those will make the difference in the game. The defense has got to tighten up on the defensive line. This game will be closer than the 10-pt spread...
The ES is in Las Vegas and will tune in on the boob-tube.
What the hell is going on? MSU scores a phenomenal 7 points against Arizona State, despite the coaches doing everything to pitch a shut out. Then, they come out and rip Northwestern 31-10? ?? This is one up-and-down team. At least we know the Spartan defense will show up... hopefully they can score.
Luckily for the Hoosiers, the MSU Homecoming Parade was cancelled due to a thunderbolt storm last night - and the skies are clear today to have the game.
Predictions:
J Rand (Nashville): MSU 42-17
Big Bob (Kzoo): MSU 21-20
Sloth (Pittsburgh): MSU 6-3
CHock (San Fran): MSU 17-16
GVSU Gregger (GVSU): MSU 21-14
RGM3 (metro D): MSU 28-10
Big Joe and Phantom 309: MSU 28-3
The Queen of Scotland (Jackson): Who gives a shit? Indiana 17-13
I am about to jump off a building. We were screwed. We played terrible. Crap. So much for the playoff.
To answer the questions posted by the ES last week:
Which team will show up? The 2012 Spartans showed up. Can't finish.
Will Tyler O'Connor show up? His real self did. Tyler O'Connor just is not a playmaker. It ain't gonna happen with him at the controls. It does not help being handcuffed by the referees.
Will Dave Warner show up? Not in overtime he didn't - the questioning leading to a time-out (and visible frustration from Coach D), followed by a pair of sacks and a missed FG left a big turd. O'Connor has GOT to throw the ball on third down - get rid of it, don't take the sack; and, well, Geiger - he Geigered it. Warner had GREAT play calling on the final drive to put MSU in position to go to OT. But, overall, fairly unimaginative.
Will the defensive line show up? Not in the second half when it mattered
Who will show up? WHAT IS WITH ALL THE PENALTIES!!!!! I give up. Look below.
MSU IND
FIRST DOWNS................... 21 19RUSHES-YARDS (NET)............ 41-175 39-156PASSING YDS (NET)............. 263 281
Passes Att-Comp-Int........... 35-21-0 28-17-1
TOTAL OFFENSE PLAYS-YARDS..... 76-438 67-437
Fumble Returns-Yards.......... 0-0 0-0
Punt Returns-Yards............ 1-1 2-31
Kickoff Returns-Yards......... 1-23 3-90
Interception Returns-Yards.... 1-0 0-0
Punts (Number-Avg)............ 5-39.4 3-38.7
Fumbles-Lost.................. 2-1 1-0
Penalties-Yards............... 11-98 7-60
Possession Time............... 33:34 26:26
Third-Down Conversions........ 4 of 15 9 of 16
Fourth-Down Conversions....... 2 of 2 0 of 1
Red-Zone Scores-Chances....... 1-1 3-4
Sacks By: Number-Yards........ 0-0 2-9
Which team will show up? Will Tyler O'Connor show up? Will Dave Warner show up? Will the defensive line show up? Will the RBs block? Who will show up? Reschke is OUT, Bullough didn't even dress last week... wha????
After Wisky lit up MSU because of our MISTAKES, I don't know where to go or what to expect. Indiana has, as typical, struggled against the sisters-of-the poor all year. This time, let's wing this prediction like a Whirling Dervish
Da ES will be up in Mt Pleasant to tailgate and witness the End of the World, CMU vs WMU... but tuning in via B1G2Go, the ES will see the Spartan O-Line getting back to basics to dictate the game, and opening up holes for LJ Scott and Gerald Holmes. Expect 175+ yards out of the two backs combined. Also, expect the maligned d-line to push up front and stop the run. Indiana has a prolific offense, as usual, but it is also prolifically mistake-prone. Who is MSU? Too tough to tell at this point.
Is the Big Green the brute that ran a 25-play drive over Iowa like a 26-wheeler over a Mac Truck? Or, is this the Big Green playing like a scared kitten in a box with a rabies-infested Rottweiler? This is more on Dave Warner and the offense. Stat to remember: MSU is 13-2 since 2010 after a loss; ain't too shabby.
I don't pretend to understand Big Ten officiating. OK, so Michigan State blew out Indiana late in its 52-26 victory on Saturday. But there were several blown calls which defy logic. You could see Coach D jawing at the officials, trying to figure out what was going through their thick skulls.
Who was the head referee? Todd Geerlings (with white hat). That was a nearly criminal performance by Geerlings and his crew. They sucked.
#1 - At the beginning of the second quarter, two phantom personal foul calls... back to back... against the Spartans. Whaaaa? Talk about a quick whistle. What the hell is going on?
#2 - The unsportsmanlike conduct penalty for excessive celebration after MSU went up 38-24. Complete BS.
#3 - And, this is the big one. How MSU did not get the football on the fumble by Indiana receiver in the third quarter? The dude spun around in a tackle, and falling forward clearly fumbled the ball. The officials called it "lack of forward progress." That's just bullshit. It's a bad call. The problem being, the week before, Michigan was at the 1/2 yard line and it took 11 seconds before the refs even blew the whistle. It doesn't take 11 seconds to run the ball 1/2 yard up the middle. That's called "lack of forward progress." You can't have it both ways, swallow the whistle or blow it - it is a lack of consistency.
The boos were deafening in Spartan Stadium after #3.
Jim Delaney and the Big Ten's Director of Officials, Bill Carollo, need to figure out what is going on. After last week's garbage, it's confirmed this is the worst officiating in Big Ten history.
The #6 MSU Spartans are 14-1/2 point favorites this week at Indiana. Here's a quick looksie at what the bookies in Vegas think about the Big Ten slate:
#6 MSU (-14 1/2) at Indiana
Minnesota (-13) vs Purdue
Maryland (-3) vs Iowa
#13 Ohio State (-20) vs Rutgers
#19 Nebraska (-7) at Northwestern
Bye week: Illinois, Michigan, Wisconsin, Penn State
After the 42-28 pounding by Michigan State over Indiana yesterday, the bookies make the Spartans an early 24-point home fave over the lowly Boilermakers from Purdue. Michigan's crushing 4-OT defeat yesterday to Penn State doesn't stop it from being a 10-pt fave over Indiana next week. Ohio State is favored by 17 over Iowa. And, Wisconsin is favored by 10 at Illinois.
Wow, MSU with nearly 500 yards of offense yesterday? 42 points? I didn't think it was possible. Incredible, particularly the 238 yards on the ground and a blistering 10-for-14 (71%) efficiency on third down.
The ES really likes Delton Williams, a big body at RB that we needed desperately. 12 carries, 92 yards, and a 7.7 average. He ran fantastic. 4 TDs and 109 yards on the ground from RB Jeremy Langford. Tony Lippett at WR had his best day as a Spartan, with 6 catches for 64 yards. The ES really loved that 34 yard TD sprint on the end-around run by RJ Shelton. Wow, what a burst of speed. And, the defense? After giving up a 64 yard run in the first minute, they gave up a whopping 28 yards on 26 carries for the rest of the game (total of 92 yards on the ground for Indiana). That's just domination.
The most hilarious play of the day? With MSU leading 42-21 early in the 4th quarter, Indiana got greedy. They received one of the few Spartan punts at their own 35, but MSU was called for an illegal motion. Instead of taking the ball at the 35, they forced the Spartans to punt over. Tisk, tisk. All-American Mike Sadler responded with a 69 yard punt, and Indiana instead started at its own 4. That defined the afternoon, and that ended any chance the Hoosiers had. The ES was roaring with laughter. Indiana coach Kevin Wilson just flat-out blew it with that bone-headed decision.
Some photos are below. Also, enjoy the stats:
IND
MSU
1st Downs
19
24
3rd down efficiency
8-18
10-14
4th down efficiency
0-1
0-0
Total Yards
351
473
Passing
259
235
Comp-Att
25-47
22-31
Yards per pass
5.5
7.6
Rushing
92
238
Rushing Attempts
27
47
Yards per rush
3.4
5.1
Penalties
7-65
10-100
Turnovers
1
2
Fumbles lost
0
1
Interceptions thrown
1
1
Possession
22:32
37:28
What a beautiful, 75 degree and sunny October day for football!
ES sez: The reality is great defense always trumps great offense. Michigan State has and will play great offenses, has and will stall all of them. This includes Indiana's #9 offense in the nation. Thus, attention turns to the Spartan offense vs the Indiana defense. Watch the Spartan defense give plenty of time for its offense to work its way with an average-to-poor Indiana defense. We don't need a lot, but we'll get enough.
Well, that sucked. Lesson learned: you GOTTA make your free throws, especially in the last 3 minutes. That Oladipo dude is amazing. Appling just didn't have his best game, shooting 1-of-8 from the field, 0-4 threes, and 4-7 FTs (including the front end of a one-and-one late).
Congrats to Indiana - they made their shots when it mattered, the Spartans didn't.
Something tells me we may see these teams play one more time, in the B1G tournament title game.
What a barn-burner. Michigan State, now standing at #4 in the nation after its whipping of Michigan and Penn State last week, is favored by a mere point over the stand-up, top-ranked #1 Indiana Hoosiers. This winner of this game may very well set the table for the regular-season, Big Ten Championship.
Tipoff is 7 pm tomorrow from the Breslin. Should be a freaking GREAT game.
Well, ain't nothin' pretty about the nasty 31-27 win at Indiana on Saturday. Coach Dantonio has plenty to be concerned about as his team spotted the Hoosiers a 17-pt lead before waking up and then shutting out Indy 17-0 in the second half to go away victorious. Note: MSU had the ball deep in Hoosier territory as they ran out the clock to end the game, maybe 38-27 is a bit more accurate.
ES said that Le'Veon Bell would have a tough time running, and sure enough had only 121 yards... and it took him 37 carries, good for a visibly-tough 3.3 yards per run. And, the ES also predicted a big day out of Maxwell, who had 290 yards through the air. Further, the ES figured on the Big Green stuffing the Hoosier running game -- for just 35 total yards on the ground.
What the ES didn't figure was the Michigan State passing defense, which fell asleep early, giving up three scoring drives totaling 215 yards in the first quarter. And, four personal fouls including a roughing the punter call. Just a very very dumb and out-of-sync MSU team. BUT, Indiana can learn a thing here: 'tis better to be good in the 4th quarter than in the 1st quarter.
What does this spell? Trouble, right here in River City, that's trouble with a capital T. In every game, this Michigan State team sleep walks through the first 25-30 minutes. They better wake up and get focused or otherwise will piss the season away. The pass defense played like arse in the first half, but played well in the 4th quarter. The potential loss via injury of Dion Sims at TE is huge - but it was nice to see Aaron Burbridge come of age with a huge game, 8 catches for 134 yards. He likely has stolen the starting spot from Tony Lippett.
Right now, the ES would say an 8-4 or 7-5 season is more likely... with difficult stints coming up vs Wisconsin, Michigan, Nebraska, and Northwestern. The way MSU has been playing, we'd be lucky to win a pair of those. But, first things first... a crappy Iowa team comes to town. Time to wake up.
MSU is favored by 10 over the Ugly Chickens -- The ES hain't confident the Spartans can score 10 against anyone. Purdue is favored by 1 hosting Wisconsin. Northwestern is favored by 3-1/2 at Minnesota. Michigan is favored by a whopping 21 at home over Illinois. Ohio State is favored by 17-1/2 at Indiana.
The Spartans did themselves no favors in the polls with their lackluster performance at Bloomington. They remain on the outside looking in. The AP poll is below; what IS interesting is that in the USA Today coaches poll, not a single Big Ten team is ranked... first time EVER.
Dropped from rankings: TCU 15, Nebraska 21, Washington 23, Northwestern 24, UCLA 25
Others receiving votes:
Ohio 79, Baylor 62, Iowa State 54, TCU 50, Michigan State 49, Arizona
State 39, Washington 39, North Carolina State 17, Nebraska 5, Arizona 4,
Duke 3, Tennessee 3, Texas Tech 2, Tulsa 2, Penn State 1, Northwestern 1
ES sez: Should be a yawner; the Hoosiers will put 8 in the box to stop Bell, and it still won't be enough. I figure Bell may get 150 on 30 carries, but won't get 200 yards because of the Hoosiers schemeing... but Maxwell may throw for 350 -- even with poor Spartan receivers. MSU defense should tee-off and have a field day with Indiana. Of note: Spartans are the only team in the nation to play three ranked teams among first five games. Final prediction: MSU 38, Indiana 10.
Well the Spartans certainly played far better on Saturday, despite being tripped up in a 17-16 tough loss to Ohio State. Anytime you play the Buckeyes, you're in for a great game. OSU's Braxton Miller is the real deal, he made it tough on a Spartan defense that held the Buckeye offense in check and out of the end zone for much of the game.
What cost MSU the game was Johnny Adams' blown coverage, giving up a 63-yard passing TD, and the defenses' inability to stop OSU and get the ball back in the final 4-minutes. Give the Buckeyes credit, they earned the win in a game of two very different teams who were fairly evenly matched. The biggest disappointment was the Spartan offensive line, which didn't find holes for LeVeon Bell and allowed Andrew Maxwell to be battered. A VERY NICE SURPRISE to see the Spartan receivers finally catch the ball. Yes, this team is improving, but it was a tough loss.
A note about the call by the refs that stopped MSU from scoring a wide open TD on the fumble recovery... Well, we still could have scored the TD, if the offense had put it in the end zone; instead, we settled for a FG off that turnover. Sure, the refs blew it, but MSU did have its chance to put score a TD anyways, and failed to do so. You gotta take advantage of the turnovers and overcome adversity. We didn't.
If MSU wants a nice bowl, or the Rose Bowl, it can't lose the rest of the year. Improvements are still needed, particularly on the O-Line.
As for this upcoming week, the opening line out of Wynn Casino in Vegas has MSU as a 15-point favorite at Indiana. Indiana gave up - get this - 394 rushing yards to Northwestern. The ES figures we can expect a real heavy dose of LeVeon Bell on Saturday. Penn State is favored by 4 at home over #24/#22 Northwestern. Wisconsin is favored by 14 at home over Illinois. Michigan is favored by 3 at Purdue. #12 Ohio State is favored at home by 4-1/2 over #21/#20 Nebraska.
And, predictably the Spartans fell out of the AP Top 25, but are on the door knocking to get back in. The two losses -- to Notre Dame and to Ohio State -- were to quality opponents with the Spartans also beating Boise State.
Ummmm... not much to write here, other than MICHIGAN STATE ABSOLUTELY POUNDED INDIANA INTO SUBMISSION. What an unbelievably complete dominating performance. ES didn't think the scoreboard had enough lights for the Spartan offense. Joel Foreman running the football was amazing. And Michigan State has found its Tight Ends. And, the Spartans found that Keshawn Martin is their top playmaker on offense.
Actually, the Spartans found everyone yesterday against the Hapless Hoosiers, and everyone was a top playmaker... for a day. 55-3? Seemed more like 100-0 to me.